St. Matthew & Our Lady of Perpetual Help Parish:

1. Fr. Robert P. Henry (2015-2022)
2. Fr. Douglas Crawford (2022-present)

Our Lady of Perpetual Help Church (1929 - 2015):

1. Fr. Gregory Mullen (1929)
2. Fr. John Dougherty
3. Fr. Gustav Schultheiss (1935-1941)
4. Fr. John J. Dalton (1941-1948)
5. Fr. Andrew F. Carney (1948-1956)
6. Msgr. William T. Greene (1956-1976)
7. Fr. Richard L. Fallon (1976-1984)
8. Fr. Hugh D. Keenan (1984-1993)
9. Fr. Robert J. Duane (1993-1997)
10. Fr. Philip Gagliano (1997-2013)
11. Fr. Matthew Fernan (2013-2015)*

1. Fr. Thomas J. Quinn (1892-1907)
2. Fr. Thomas O'Keefe (1907-1940)
3. Fr. Thomas F. Kane (1940-1948)
4. Msgr. Aloysius F. Karl (1948-1962)
5. Msgr. William V. O'Connor (1962-1968)
6. Msgr. William J. Kenealy (1968-1986)
7. Msgr. Edward J. McCorry (1986-2004)
8. Fr. Matthew Fernan (2004-2015)

St. Stanislaus Kostka Church (1912 - 2007):

1. Msgr. Joseph C. Dworzak (1912-1918)
2. Fr. Aloysius Filetz (1918-1925)
3. Fr. Vincent F. Daszkiewicz (1926-1963)
4. Msgr. Edward Fabisinki (1964-1969)
5. Fr. Roman J. Szarama (1969-1977)
6. Msgr. Edward Fabisinki (1977-1986)
7. Msgr. Edward J. McCorry (1986-2004)
8. Fr. Matthew Fernan (2004-2007)